She saw daddy kissing Santa Claus

The Harvey Milk Elementary School Christmas Holiday Pageant

Conceived and directed by Scott Gilmore
Music director David Delaney
NativeAliens Theatre Collective
The Flatiron Playhouse
119 West 23rd St., Suite 305 (726-8891)
Equity approved production (through December 14)
Review by David Mackler

Although the title of NativeAliens Theatre Collectiveís The Harvey Milk Elementary School Christmas Holiday Pageant might lead to the expectation of a camp-filled romp at the expense of all thatís held dear about the December holidays, the conception (by director Scott Gilmore) is far more subtle than that. Mrs. Reed (Gilmore) greets the parents/audience and advises that this pageant was put together by the students, and that she and the school cannot be held accountable for what we are about to see.

To be sure, there are the some terrifically over-the-top numbers: the new lyrics to "Who Put the Bomp (In the Bomp, Bomp, Bomp)" are sung by Jeff Seabaugh, an angel at the top of a Christmas tree, as "Who Put the Stump (In My Rump, Rump, Rump)"; thereís a delightfully loony "Twelve Days of Christmas," stolen by Maureen Cantaraís "six geese a-laying" and Helen Bessetteís not-quite-certainty that the partridge in a pear tree was secure on her head. The real sense is that this pageant is almost exactly what school kids would offer if given their own authority to stage a holiday show. Some of it is sweetly heartfelt showing-off (Nancy Rogersís "Iíll be Home for Christmas"), some tasteless juvenilia (a "Carol of the Bells" that becomes more and more oppressive to poor, tortured Lisa Shaheen), some things that kids would consider cutting edge that are humorous in ways the kids wouldnít understand (a hip-hop "White Christmas" done as if it were Vanilla Iceís "Ice Ice Baby").

Thereís a sense, too, that much of the stuff is at a level older than elementary school, but then there will be something like "Melekalikimaka" (you know, that Christmas hula), where Inga Hyatt gets just right the awkward attempt at smoothness and the wild-eyed terror of a kid whoís not quite sure why sheís up on stage. She was similarly funny as part of the group performing "Sleigh Ride," and her solo "I Saw Daddy Kissing Santa Claus." And just when it seems that for elementary-schoolers these kids fidget, scratch, and twitch very little, in the middle of "The Dreidle Song" Hyatt runs off the stage, badly in need of a bathroom. Jodi Lynn Smith also captured a childlike enjoyment of performing with "Blue Christmas," where she wouldnít let her glee at singing on stage be hidden behind the mask she carried.

Thereís quite a lot of very good singing (Samara Doucetteís "A Place Called Home"), "The Little Drummer Boy" (Tyler Ashby Jones); as well as more stuff the kids would find funnier than their audience ("Santa Baby" with Shenan Reed Golimbu; "Suzi Snow Flake," with Doucette and Jones; and a take-off on smarmy Christmas TV specials). But then thereís perfection in the gratuitously token appearance of a song about Kwanzaa, and the wonderful, completely erroneous pronunciation of Hebrew words in "Hava Negila" and "To Life" (from Fiddler on the Roof). Delaney has contributed an original song, "With You Itís Christmas" that stands proudly with the classics.

The costumes showed that the kids had the help of supportive parents (designed by Mary Morris and Cynthia Russell), and Kim Parkerís lighting similarly showed that more than an English teacher was in charge of illumination. The kids (and the performers) are having lots of fun so in the end, it doesnít matter if it would appeal mainly to the kids' only-this-far-developed sense of humor. This sort of thing knows no sexual orientation, and even if itís a little too subtle for its own good, itís hard to resist.

Also with Alice Bugman, Caroline Smith, Mary Tarochione.

Box Score:

Concept: 2
Directing: 1
Performance: 2
Sets: 1
Costumes: 1
Lighting/Sound: 1

Return to Volume Nine, Number nineteen Index

Return to Volume Nine Index

Return to Home Page

Copyright 2002 David Mackler